|
|
What is Panic
Disorder/Agoraphobia?
"I was at home, watching TV, sitting on my
favorite coach. It had been an exhausting day, but at last, I was at home.
Suddenly, I noticed a strong beat in my heart, and it began again, the
palpitations, the dizziness. I felt myself fainting. I couldn’t do anything at
all to stop it, and the worst thing happened, I couldn’t breath. In just a
moment I felt myself dying, it was a heart attack, I was sure this time. I
called my wife and asked her to take me to hospital and again the same story:
"It is a panic attack, you are not in danger at all". The doctor gave
me a pill and I started feeling better in a while".
Panic disorder essential feature is the presence of unexpected panic
attacks as the described above, which are attacks of fear or discomfort in which
the individual experiences intense bodily sensations (palpitations, trembling,
shortness of breath, etc.). These attacks have a sudden onset, build up to a
peak rapidly (usually in 10 minutes or less), and are accompanied by a sense of
imminent danger and an urge to escape. PD is usually accompanied by Agoraphobia
(Ag) (Panic Disorder with Agoraphobia, PDA) (DSM-IV APA, 1994), namely, a
cluster of fears whose common feature is anxiety about being in places or
situations from which escape might be difficult (or embarrassing), or in which
help may not be available in the event of having a panic attack or panic-like
symptoms. This fear leads to a pervasive avoidance involving several situations:
being outside one’s home alone, being in a crowd, travelling in a bus,
automobile or train, being in an elevator or on a bridge, etc.
Patients with PDA show a persistent concern about the possible
implications or consequences of the panic attacks, or they think the panic
attack indicate the presence of a severe illness, despite repeated medical
testing and reassurance. Others are convinced panic attacks are the indication
that they are "going crazy", or losing control, or being emotionally
weak. Many patients usually show constant or intermittent feelings of anxiety
that are not focused on any specific situation, excessive worry about health, or
about separation from loved ones. Moreover, the feature of "unexpectedness"
of panic attacks, accompanied by the patients’ subjective perception that they
have no control over the problem or over the somatic symptoms, leads to a sense
of helplessness (Botella & Ballester, 1997).
PDA usually imply a significant change in the patients’ lives, and is
often accompanied by several other problems, such as:
·
Important problems in interpersonal relationships: family, friends, work
colleagues, etc.
·
Demoralization. They often attribute this problem to a
lack of "strength" or "character".
·
Mayor Depressive Disorder (50%-65%).
·
Alcohol or medication intake to treat their anxiety.
·
High comorbidity with other Anxiety Disorders: such as
Social Phobia (15%-30%), Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (8%-10%), Specific
Phobias (10%-20%), Generalized Anxiety Disorder (25%).
DSM-IV (APA, 1994) states that epidemiological studies throughout the
world (APA, 1994, Kessler et al.,
1994) indicate the lifetime prevalence or PD (with or without Ag) is ranging
between 1,5% and 3,5%. To these data, we have to add the social and financial
implications of PD. A high percentage of panic sufferers are in their most
productive age, and a significant number of them drop out work, due to the
incapacity the problem creates. Because of that, PDA is considered as an
important public health problem, due to its high prevalence, its resistance to
spontaneous remission, its comorbidity with other disorders such as alcoholism,
drug abuse, and depression, and the important negative consequences to the panic
sufferers quality of life. (Margraf, Barlow, Clark, & Telch, 1993).
What is our treatment program
about?
Components:
Psychoeducation, cognitive therapy, breathing re-training, in vivo exposure, VR
exposure, and relapse prevention.
Treatment components
Psychoeducation
It
consists of giving a clear explanation about what PDA is and of clarifying
concepts such as fear and anxiety. The survival value of anxiety is addressed,
as well as the fact that it is harmless. The different manifestations of anxiety
are also discussed (physiological, cognitive, and behavioral). We highlight the
central role that the cognitive component has in anxiety and, concretely, in the
development of a panic attack. We expose a cognitive model of panic attacks and
we encourage the patient to pose all the doubts and questions about the model.
Then we propose the patient to carry out a behavioral exercise: we make the
patient hyperventilate in order to learn more about the development of his/her
panic attacks and about the role of hyperventilation in his panic attacks and
its physiological effects.
Breathing
re-training.
The
goal of this component is to change a fast breathing pattern by a slow breathing
pattern. A common response to anxiety provoking situations is hyperventilation.
The consequences of hyperventilation are the intensification or the appearance
of several physiological symptoms that intensify anxiety. In our treatment for
PDA, patients are taught a slow breathing technique to face the anxiety
provoking situations in a more effective way.
Cognitive
therapy.
An
important issue regarding our responses to events or situations is the way we
interpret them, what we think about those situations and their meaning. The way
we think will determine how we will feel about things. Sometimes we make
erroneous interpretations that can lead to distressing feelings. Applying
cognitive techniques means trying to behave as scientists do: test if our
interpretations are right or wrong, find alternative ways of thinking about the
situations that would lead to less distressing feelings and allow us to face the
situations in a more competent way. In our treatment for panic disorder the
therapist shows how to identify, challenge, and combat the catastrophic
misinterpretations that the patient makes of his/her symptoms while having a
panic attack. With the indications from the therapist, the patient learns to
look for objective interpretations about the consequences of his/her bodily
sensations during a panic attack. This is a better way of facing panic attacks
and decrease panic frequency.
In vivo exposure and exposure to
interoceptive cues.
If
we met someone who wanted to ride a bicycle, but who fell down when he tried it,
what would we advice him? Probably, we would tell that person to ride the
bicycle again. The best way to overcome a fear is facing it. In vivo exposure
consists of facing the fear provoking situations gradually and progressively,
staying in the situation until the fear or anxiety goes down. In our treatment
to panic disorder, we elaborate with the patient an individualized hierarchy
with his/her feared situations and he/she carries out exposure exercises to face
gradually those situations. Also, the patient exposes him/herself to the feared
bodily sensations that appear in the panic attacks.
VR
exposure.
This
form of exposure presents some advantages if we compare it to traditional
exposure: it provides safety to the patient and to the therapist; they can
control the context generated by the computer at will and without risks, since
it can be absolutely graded. Therefore, VR can be an intermediate step between
the therapist's consulting room (where the patient feels safe and protected) and
the real environment (so threatening for some patients that they decide not to
face it). It is easier to repeat the same exposure tasks once and again without
leaving the therapist’s office. This implies an important saving in cost and
time. Finally, VR exposure allows designing a tailored hierarchy for the patient
to expose him/herself to all the possible situations, and even to impossible
ones. In our treatment of PDA, there are a great number of situations related to
agoraphobic avoidance that the patient uses to avoid to prevent the occurrence
of panic attacks. By means of the immersion in different VR scenarios, the
person can face and overcome his/her fear.
VR
scenarios
First
scenario: At home.
-
At
this first scenario the patient stays at his/her living-room at home and he/she
listens a message at the answering machine with instructions about what he/she
has to buy at the department store.
-
When
he/she leaves the room, he/she finds a very large passage and at the end
there is an elevator. This elevator has been designed to offer different
possibilities related with agoraphobic fear, taking into account several
factors (amount of people, position and the possibility of blocking the
elevator).
Second
scenario: The bus
At this
scenario the patient is at the bus stop, gets into the bus, when he is in it he
can move anywhere he likes and he can look at any direction he prefers, he can
see people inside the bus, the streets the bus is circulating by, people that is
getting up and down the bus,… Several aspects can be also modulated in this
setting, like amount of people, duration of the travel, number of stops the bus
makes.
Third
scenario: The subway.
This scenario
is very similar to the last one, but now the patient stays at the station
waiting for the next train, but the patient can make the same actions, and it
can be modulated the same agoraphobic factors.
Fourth
scenario: Department
Stores
The
department stores have two plants, on the first one there are books and music
sections, at the second one there are food and clothes sections. The patient has
to look for some articles, depending on the instructions he/she has received at
home and he/she must pay at the cashbox. Some things can be modified in this
setting too, like amount of people. There is also the possibility of a person
blocking the pass in the middle of a passage, or the patient can have troubles
to pay at the cashbox.
Fifth
scenario: The tunnel
At the
tunnel the person can walk, run or stay stopped and he can look at any direction.
All the
scenarios permit to make interoceptive exposition by making the patient listen
to his/her own heart rhythm, breathing or vision effects (double vision, blurry,…)
|
|